Art: A Brief (Western) History

When you think of a school textbook, you think of long paragraphs, boring tired pages, and God forbid—math textbooks filled to the brim with pages of equations. School textbooks are meant to provide factual unbiased information on that topic. Now, what happens when you read a textbook that you can clearly sense there is some bias towards one group or culture? Sure, the ideas and information might be 100% fact, but when you present information in a biased manner, some ideas may be overlooked or underrepresented.  
The textbook, Art: A Brief History by Marilyn Stokstad and Michael Cothren, shows a major bias towards the West, or more explicitly, Europe, Australia, and the Americas. Although the textbook does an awesome job of representing and relaying details of specific works of art as well as their historical context, there is a definite difference in how some pieces are described and portrayed and they are not of the same caliber, in fact, they are far from each other. This is a strong injustice, and if it’s not criticized, it won’t change. Just to show you exactly how this bias is practiced in this textbook, we will be discussing two pieces, the Stele of Hammurabi (Figure 1) and the Greek Parthenon (Figure 2).

Figure 1 - Stele of Hammurabi

Figure 2 - Parthenon 

    First, when you simply read, no not even read, when you simply SKIM the passages for the individual pieces, you can already feel that sense of bias. For starters, there is a dominant difference in length. Length, as frivolous as it seems, can show bias. The Stele of Hammurabi has 160 words under its belt, and that's not including the caption from its figure photo. While the Greek Parthenon has a whopping 946 words, and that’s not including the captions from the figure photos of the many different components of the building. Of course, you can argue that the Parthenon is on a greater scale in size and has different components such as marble statues or the narrative friezes that require lots of detail, but come on, the Stele of Hammurabi is one of the first forms of written laws! How is it that there is so much to stay about the Parthenon, but out of the 160 words about the Stele of Hammurabi, not even one single law was quoted and translated in the main passage? Sure, the passage says that 68 out of the 300 laws relate to domestic life and that 20 deal with physical assault (Stokstad & Cothren, 41), but why not give an example of one or even both types of laws? If the textbook is going to indicate specifics about the number of laws that relate to home life as well as physical assault, it should have also included an example of these laws in the main passage. Instead, you can find more details in the caption of the Stele of Hammurabi’s figure photo. Here you can find some laws, such as an eye for an eye, a broken bone for a broken bone, even some punishments pertaining to the death penalty (Stokstad & Cothren, 41). It’s great that the textbook includes captioned graphics, as they contain greater detail, but the stele’s main purpose was to be public posts placed around the Babylonian kingdom, it would make more sense to add these examples of laws in the main passage. That would have been a great addition to the main passage as it would provide more context and an idea of how life when these steles stood.  
However, when discussing the Parthenon, no detail is apparently too little. The textbook dives into very specific visual descriptions of the Parthenon.  Descriptions of “builders using the finest white marble”, commenting on how the “columns have a subtle swelling and tilt inward slightly toward the center of the building” as well as how the “subtle refinements in the arrangement of seemingly regular elements give the Parthenon a buoyant organic appearance and prevent it from looking like a heavy, lifeless stone box” (Stokstad & Cothren, 112). These phrases are abounding with detail. By including deeply descriptive words, one can easily construct an image of the Parthenon. Yet the visual description given about the Stele of Hammurabi does not have the same type of care or attention. The only descriptive sentence of the Stele itself visually is “the code, incised in cuneiform script on a stele, appears under a portrait of the ruler standing before the enthroned supreme judge and the sun god, Shamash, patron of law and justice.” (Stokstad & Cothren, 41). I couldn’t even tell you what color the stele is given that description. The textbook could have easily gone more into depth about its structure, it’s overall shape, the material it’s made from, and even the context of the “portrait” atop of the stele, but it fails to do so. In this failure, the Stele of Hammurabi is ridiculously diminished and depreciated in comparison to the dominating Parthenon. 




In all social and political conflicts, the winner is usually the one who claims what is right or wrong. This often includes rewriting the history of the conquered opposition, or having complete authority over how a society behaves.  On top of that, they can claim ownership of historical artifacts – spoils of war. Spoils of war can be defined as any profits gained after the result of winning a war or political conflict. Such examples include the Stele of Naram-Sin (Figure 3) and the Stele of Hammurabi. As Art: A Brief History explains it, there was an Elamite King of Susa who brought both steles into Elamite Susa from Mesopotamia as military trophies. This Elamite king had the audacity to add an inscription into the Stele of Naram-Sin, explaining that he meant to “protect” it. As we look over history today, we can clearly see that this is a fabricated lie. This can then be connected to more modern Western history, “In the nineteenth century, the British Lord Elgin purchased and removed Classical Greek reliefs from the Parthenon in Athens... Although his actions may have protected the reliefs from neglect and damage in later wars, they have remained installed in the British Museum, despite continuing protests from Greece” (Stokstad & Cothren, 35). In this example, the West has taken artwork from the Parthenon, despite Greek protests, and used that art to fabricate the lie that they simply mean to preserve the reliefs from neglect and damage from war. Although they had permission from the Ottoman authorities who governed over Greece at the time, the British Lord Elgin just wanted to decorate the British Museum with unique, one-of-a-kind reliefs despite the pleas of the Greek people. Although both the Elamite king and the British participated in taking pieces of art, the textbook describes the action very differently. When regarding the West, the textbook almost passes blame. For example, they say “most of the works of sculpture from the Parthenon have been damaged or lost over the centuries...” (Stokstad & Cothren, 112). When we know that they weren’t simply “lost” they were taken by the West, just as the Marble Elgin statues were. Just as the Elamite king stole the Stele of Haram-Sin from Mesopotamia and claimed to protect its value, the British Lord Elgin took the Greek reliefs from the Parthenon and claimed to protect it from the damage of war, when he just wanted to add a collector’s value to the British Museum. This goes to show that the textbook favors Western perspective as it does not criticize the West as it does the King of Susa.  

When it comes to introducing a certain part of history in a textbook, the authors try to include as much valid information as possible. The Stele of Hammurabi was not given enough information to show its importance to the Middle Eastern cultures. From what the authors wrote, they explain that “Hammurabi was breaking new ground by regulating laws and punishments rather than leaving them to the whims of rulers and officials.” (Stokstad and Cothren, 41) Most of the information that the authors used just scratches the surface. The Stele is a message of law and order, but the authors missed its meaning to their religion and the culture of the Babylonians. The Stele of Hammurabi does not get the same treatment as what the Parthenon got. The authors implement more significance to the Parthenon which include religion, culture, detail, and architecture compared to the Stele of Hammurabi. The authors took the time to also include the marble friezes within the Parthenon in which they describe them as, “92 carved metopes with scenes of victory.” (Stokstad and Cothren, 114). Although the Hammurabi doesn’t have as much artifacts as the Parthenon, the authors really went in depth with everything in the Parthenon including the friezes that it becomes clear of what the Parthenon signifies.  

 Art: A Brief History is a textbook that takes a dive into art pieces found around the world. However, the explanations and details from certain groups and cultures give a certain bias that makes it appropriate for Western society. They do a good job explaining the main points and importance of each art piece, but they mostly deliver specific and highly detailed explanations to art pieces found in the Western world misleading the readers from the importance of art works in Eastern cultures. The biased statements to art works in Eastern cultures eliminates the context and formality that a textbook is supposed to be as it becomes an act of misinformation to students who have a passion with analyzing and learning about art pieces from all around the world.

Art Detective: 

Figure 3 - USNA, Bancroft Hall

(Alexi) In (Figure 3) the main door entrance of the United States Naval Academy’s Bancroft Hall is a large door under a grand arch (rounded semi-circular doorway) that looks almost carved out from the building. On both sides of the door, one can see two Doric columns on each side of the door. I’ve classified them as Doric Order due to their thick shaft, non-decorative base, as well as their plain capital, or top of the column. Finally, the very high relief tympanum or decorative semicircular wall is between the lintel and arch of the entrance. The tympanum has a relief of tridents which are symbolic of the sea (given it’s in the Naval Academy), as well as two reliefs of armor, an eagle, two torches to symbolize eternal flames, and finally a relief of the front face of a ship. I considered these as high reliefs because they are so deeply carved out, they almost look like they are popping out from the wall. gfdgf 

Figure 5 - UC Berkeley, Hearst Greek Theatre
   



Figure 6 - Malibu California, Getty Villa M










Comments